Picardy Place, Edinburgh

 
 

Sensitive, bespoke and sustainable repurposing of a vacant listed building into a boutique hotel in the heart of Edinburgh.

The development represents a successful example of the adaptive reuse of a vacant Category B-listed property within the Edinburgh's New Town Conservation Area and the Old and New Towns of Edinburgh World Heritage Site.

The scheme repurposes a former car rental facility in the city centre, transforming it into an independent hotel comprising 51 guest rooms, a restaurant and a bar lounge.

Prior to the current intervention, the building had undergone a commercially driven redevelopment involving the insertion of an encased steel and concrete structure, intended to maximise the number of floors accommodated within the existing building envelope. However, this approach gave limited consideration to the heritage significance and architectural character of the listed building. As a result, the arrangement of car lifts, stair cores and circulation routes was prioritised over a sensitive response to the historic fabric and wider architectural context.

AT A GLANCE

LOCATION - 10 Picardy Place, New Town, Edinburgh

CLIENT - Edinburgh Picardy Place Ltd

STATUS- On site

 

REPURPOSING THE HISTORIC BUILDING

The internal floor levels were determined primarily by the structural constraints and overall height of the building, rather than by the proportions and fenestration pattern of the historic façade. This is particularly evident where floor slabs intersect existing window openings and where some internal rooms have window cill heights of approximately 2 metres. These interventions significantly compromise the relationship between the internal spaces and the historic façade, highlighting the challenges associated with reconciling commercial requirements with the sensitive adaptation of a listed building.

For Hackland + Dore Architects, the repurposing of the building required a design approach that worked with its inherent structural constraints and the significance of its listed façade. To address the impact of the existing floor slabs on the historic façade, the proposal removes the sections of slab that intersect the window openings and introduces a new, lightweight glazed façade set back from the rear of the listed elevation. This creates a clear separation between the internal floor structure and the historic façade, allowing the two to function independently while removing the visual intrusion of floor slabs bisecting the existing windows.

The bespoke intervention establishes a deliberately subservient secondary façade behind the Georgian frontage. Its restrained architectural expression ensures that the new insertion neither competes with nor detracts from the historic elevation, preserving the prominence and integrity of the listed building within its immediate context and the wider Palace setting.

ADDED VALUE

The rear of the building is extended with the addition of two storeys. Natural daylight is also reintroduced into the heart of the building through the removal of the existing metal roof and its supporting steel trusses, creating a full-height atrium. This central void forms an open, landscaped courtyard around which the hotel accommodation is arranged, bringing light and a renewed sense of spatial quality into the depth of the existing building.